JOURNAL ARTICLE

Studi Hadis di Kalangan Orientalis (Studi atas Pandangan Ignaz Goldziher dan Joseph Schacht)

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to analyze the views of orientalists in the study of Hadith, especially according to Goldziher and Schacht, and present a rebuttal to these opinions in order to create a balance in understanding the reading. Orientalism is often defined as Westerners studying the Eastern world. The orientalists in conducting Islamic studies, especially in studying the Hadith, are not all the same. In this paper, a literature review derived from several books related to the views of Hadith studies among Orientalists is used. As for the results of this paper on the views of Hadith studies among Orientalists according to Goldziher and Schacht, Orientalists are not all the same in viewing Islam. There are different opinions about Islam in the Hadith. This view is inseparable from how they judge the Prophet Muhammad because the Hadith is inseparable from everything related to the Prophet. In this paper, the author also adds a little rebuttal to the opinion in order to create a balance in reading comprehension.

Keywords:
Philosophy Humanities Theology Art Classics

Metrics

0
Cited By
0.00
FWCI (Field Weighted Citation Impact)
6
Refs
0.11
Citation Normalized Percentile
Is in top 1%
Is in top 10%

Topics

Qur’anic Interpretation Studies
Social Sciences →  Social Sciences →  Education
Education and Islamic Studies
Social Sciences →  Social Sciences →  Education
Islamic Studies and Radicalism
Social Sciences →  Social Sciences →  Sociology and Political Science

Related Documents

JOURNAL ARTICLE

Alqur’an dan Hadis dalam Pandangan Orientalis: Studi Pemikiran Ignaz Goldziher

Ahlal KamalMuhammad HendriSandy Aulia Rahman

Journal:   Al-Muhith Jurnal Ilmu Qur an dan Hadits Year: 2024 Vol: 2 (1)Pages: 61-61
JOURNAL ARTICLE

TEORI-TEORI IGNAZ GOLDZIHER DALAM STUDI HADIS

Syamsul Arifin

Journal:   PUTIH JURNAL PENGETAHUAN TENTANG ILMU DAN HIKMAH Year: 2021 Vol: 5 (1)Pages: 15-52
JOURNAL ARTICLE

ANALISIS FAKTOR KONEKSITAS KRITIK HADIS ANTARA IGNAZ GOLDZIHER DAN JOSEPH SCHACHT

Vrisko Putra Vachruddin

Journal:   Multidisciplinary Indonesian Center Journal Year: 2024 Vol: 1 (1)Pages: 138-155
© 2026 ScienceGate Book Chapters — All rights reserved.