In this note we give a direct proof using the theory of modular forms of a beautiful fact explained in the preceding paper by Robbert Dijkgraaf [1, Theorem 2 and Corollary]. Let $$ {\tilde M_*}({\Gamma _1}) $$ denote the graded ring of quasi-modular forms on the full modular group Γ= PSL(2, ℤ). This is the ring generated by G2, G4, G6, and graded by assigning to each G k the weight where $$ {G_k} = - \frac{{{B_k}}}{{2k}} + \sum\limits_{n = 1}^\infty {\left( {{{\sum\limits_{d|n} d }^{k - 1}}} \right)} {q^n}\left( {k \geqslant 2,{B_k} = kth Bernoulli number} \right) $$ are the classical Eisenstein series, all of which except G 2 are modular.
Siegfried H. LehnigkG. F. Roach
Tewodros AmdeberhanLeonid G. FelKen Ono